** I am currently working to create a much more reader friendly system of diaper reviews, so you don’t have to read these SUPER long review posts! I am working to get each diaper their own post under the category “Off the Bum.” Check out that category on the sidebar for more cloth diaper reviews! And if you have any cloth diaper related questions, feel free to ask! **
Now that I’ve used my one size cloth diapers longer and on growing kids, I felt like I should re-review them. I’ve gotten to know each diaper a little better and can now add a little to the endurance of each diaper.
Here are the stats on the diaper users:
Imogene- 3 years old. Size 3T – 4 clothing. ~35 lbs. ~39″ tall. Average 3 year old. Difficult fit issue: very large thighs. Currently potty learning and only wear diapers at night.
Aidan- 2 years old. Size 24 month clothing. ~25 lbs. ~36″ tall. Average 2 year old. Difficult issue: heavy wetter. Currently potty introducing, but still wears diapers all the time.
Emery- 2 months old. Size 6 month clothing. ~15 lbs. ~22″ tall. Difficult issue: newborn poo. Difficult fit issues: Very large thinghs. Currently EBF infant in diapers all the time.
Haute Pocket One Size Pockets. This photo is the “breathable” version. I also have a few of the “traditional” version. The newer version (traditional) is slightly bigger than the breathable version. I do love these diapers, but have found fit issues. The inner fleece is still so soft even after many, many washings. I did have the PUL mess up (bad) on one of the green “breathable” diapers. Not sure why, but the laminate layer pulled away from the polyester layer and melted/stuck to itself. (PUL “peeled” I guess.) It is unusable. It only happened to one so far, though they are all washed together daily. Despite that, I still like this diaper. I do have to use the doubler (comes with the diaper insert) all the time for Aidan. Fit issues: Too small for Imogene. The thighs are too tight and the waist is very snug on its loosest setting. The “traditional” version do fit her a little better, but I only use them on her when I have no other option. On Emery, when the rise is at its smallest (which it has to be) the inner fleece has a tendency to flip to the outside, wicking urine to his clothing. I can sometimes tuck the fleece in really well when I am putting it on him and avoid this, but if he wiggles too much or is passed around obsessively it will work its way out and he’ll leak. (Could make a fun “hot potato” style game. Whoever is holding the bay when he leaks has to change him!) I would say the realistic fit of these diapers is 7 lbs. to 30 lbs. I would still buy more of these diapers, though I think Emery might outgrow them before potty learning. The price is good for the diaper!
Blueberry Deluxe and Swaddlebees Econappi One Size Pocket Diaper. These are good quality diapers. I have had one back seam on my Econappi unravel a bit, but nothing that has yet made it unwearable or required me to fix it. I imagine it will require fixing in a month or so. The Blueberry has nice thick fleece. It does pill over time, but still feels comfortable. I tried these as all-in-twos as the manufacturer says you can, but it didn’t work out. The ”cover” always got soiled with the insert. I really only use them as pockets. With the older two, these leak when they are running around playing. The absorbency is great for Aidan, if he doesn’t wiggle the insert around too much. These are good for long car rides and even bedtime if the kids don’t move around too much or play too much before going to bed. Over time, the cotton velour interior of the Econappi isn’t as soft. It can sometimes feel pretty stiff, but the kids never complain about it. They do feel wetter with the cotton velour. (It doesn’t wick moisture away as well as fleece, but that aspect doesn’t bother me or the kids.) These fit all three kids just fine. The realistic fit on these diapers is 10 lbs. to 35+ lbs. I do like these, but I think they are overpriced for what you get. Overall, they have held up well.
Happy Heiny One Size Pocket. Functionally, I like this diaper. Overall, this diaper is the thorn in my flesh! Good first? Okay. This diaper has the most generous fit of any we own. So, this is the diaper of choice for Imogene and her thunder thighs. This diaper is absorbent and works well for overnight with a doubler. The fit of Emery is good. It doesn’t seem to squeeze his thighs too much. The back elastic seems tight on all the kids. The inside fleece pills, but is still soft. This diaper is a terrible fit on Aidan. The best fit on him is with one row of snaps down, but even then it just seems off. The laundry tabs on this diaper never hold the velcro tabs. It grabs and snags my other diapers in the wash. Often, I have to carefully pry it off something before putting it in the dryer (re-securing the laundry tabs) and then prying it off something else in the dryer. You definitely need the HH insert for this diaper, it will leak because of the shape with anything else. It looks terrible now after being washed so many times. The Velcro tabs just look ratty and I have to pry strings and lint out of them all the time. I doubt I will ever buy another HH. However, the size range is impressive. Realistically, this diaper will fit from 8 lbs. to 40 lbs. (possibly more) I would maybe like this diaper with snaps (and they do make them), I’m just not willing to purchase another one to see. (If a free one came my way, I’d give it an enthusiastic try!)
bumGenius 3.0 One Size Pocket. I have the version with the suedecloth interior. They did have a special edition of fleece. (Fleece would be a good improvement to this diaper. So would SNAPS!) I am not a suedecloth fan. None of my kids have reactions to the suedecloth (have heard of some kids being allergic) but it is not the nicest feeling stuff to have on your bum. Feels like polyester felt. My second problem with this diaper is the velcro, or aplix as they call it in the cloth diaper world. I’m very anti-aplix. The aplix tabs looks terrible. The laundry tabs on this diaper work fairly well. The few times this diaper has grabbed onto something in the wash, I’m thinking SOMEONE forgot to fasten the tabs before throwing it in the diaper pail. But the tabs still look terrible. They don’t hold as well as they once did. (I may have another 6 months on it before the aplix fails completely.) I have had to hand pick strings and lint out of the aplix on several occasions. Also to note, don’t put pantyhose or tights over this diaper. The aplix will snag and run the pantyhose or tights. These fit all three really well. I somehow lost the insert that came with it (not sure how that happens) but was able to easily replace it with a Nicki’s Diapers insert. These work well overnight with a double. I don’t have problem with these leaking. These diapers are cleverly made! When they are on the smallest setting, like all diapers, the interior tends to peek out a bit. These have a strip of PUL all around the interior waist, so they don’t leak! Good thinking guys. Realistically, these fit from 8 lbs. to 35 lbs. I won’t buy any more of these because of the aplix, though. If they made one with snaps and fleece, it’d be a dream come true! But the lifetime of the aplix gives this diaper a short life span, and I need diapers that last!
bumGenius One Size Organic All-in-one with snaps. So, though my first reviews of this diaper were less than favorable, I have since seen the light. To be honest, this is now my favorite diaper. I wish The Pastor could see the light and buy more! My main complaint before was the drying time. Well, I have since found diapers that take MUCH longer to dry. (Fitteds and some WAHM AIOs.) These barely take longer to dry that pockets, which is pretty good for something so absorbant. I love the cotton interior. (Though I am often at a loss of where to put the doubler on the rare occasion Aidan wears it to bed.) I only need a doubler if Aidan wears this diaper to bed. This diaper has held up beautifully. The interior is pretty stained (the cotton stains more than fleece or suedecloth) but the exterior looks like I just bought the thing. I haven’t tried to get the stains out because they don’t really bother me (it is a diaper, you know). It has the nifty PUL band around the interior waistband that prevents the insides from peeking out and leaking. (Genius!) The snaps are still holding up well, despite many uses. (This diaper gets used and washed at least once a day!) These diapers are a little more expensive, but well worth $25 (unlike the Blueberry & Econappi). Not that pockets are difficult, but on super busy days, I think to myself, “It’d be nice if every diaper I owned was ready from the dryer like this and could just be tossed into the diaper pail with no extra anything.” Honestly, if I were rebuying my entire stash right now, I’d buy 2 dozen of these and call it a day. The Pastor has still not seen the vast awesomeness of this diaper. The realistic fit of these diapers is 8 lbs. to 35 lbs.
Rocky Mountain One Size Pocket. I really wanted to like these. I would love to tell you I fell in love with them after my negative review, but I did not. They have the stiff suedecloth interior that I don’t like. (Although, it is a color, which is cute and fun and doesn’t show stains quite so badly.) I bought a Nicki’s Diapers insert for this diaper. It fits well and works fine. This diaper is tiny! It does not fit Imogene at all. It adjusts to smaller rises by pulling and snapping the elastic in the leg casing. It is a pain in the butt to do. The elastic sticks to the PUL while you’re trying to pull it through. You’ve also got to count and recount to make sure you’ve got them even on both sides. Then you have to tuck the excess into the “wings” on the diaper, where the bunch up on baby’s hips. Not a very convenient feature when you’ve got various sized kids wearing the diaper. Emery has large thighs, but he’d still a little guy, so the smaller leg opening to smaller rise thing doesn’t work well with him. They are expensive diapers for what you get. ($18 for the diaper plus $3 for the insert.) The snaps in the leg casing can also put too much pressure on fat thighs. This diaper does still look just like it did when I bought it, but I hate using it. It gets used last, if at all. This diaper is a waste of money. (The only way this diaper would be remotely worth buying is if it was $10.) The realistic fit on this diaper is 8 lbs. to 25 lbs.
Smartipants One Size Diaper. We recently bought 4 of these to try. They are really cheap, so we were hoping to find the perfect diaper at the perfect price. (They were $39.95 for a 3 pack, including inserts.) I have to say, I like these. I don’t love them, but I like them. They have suedecloth interior like bumGenius diapers. The fit is very similar to a bumGenius or Haute Pocket. They would realistically fit from 8 lbs. to 35 lbs. I love that it has snaps. I like that they are made in the USA. The weird thing about these diapers, is that they aren’t exactly a pocket. These diapers have a “sleeve.” It is a rectangular “sleeve” sewn onto the diaper that opens at the front and back of the diaper. You slide an insert into the sleeve. This is a little difficult to make sure the insert stays inside the diaper at the smaller rise settings, but it can be done with a little practice. The benefit of the “sleeve” is that you don’t remove the insert before throwing it in the diaper pail. (Once again, pocket diapers are not difficult in the least, but the removal of a small step can be big when you’re busy! It is also fabulous when you’ve been out all day and come home with your wet bag of dirty diapers to just be able to toss them all in the pail and not have to pull the inserts out of the cold, wet diapers.) I have only had these for a few weeks, so I’ll update you later when I get all the kinks worked out with them. At first, I loved them. Now, I’m not as sure. We’ve been having leaking problems with all the kids. I’m not sure if the inserts just don’t hold as much as I would like them to or if the “sleeve” design creates room to leak from the sides. I’m also not a suedecloth fan, so these are starting at a slight disadvantage. Hopefully I can work through the leaking issue and these will be wonderful diapers. I haven’t given up on them just yet!